Instructions
HEC-HMS version 4.14 was used in this tutorial.
Download the initial project files here:
Fix_Me.zip
This HEC-HMS model, based off a model of Mahoning Creek at Punxsutawney, PA, is riddled with intentional defects. Some defects are “loud”, where an ERROR is triggered and the compute fails. Some defects are “silent”, where the compute is successful, but results are not as expected. Your job is to identify and resolve all model defects (hint: there are 17) and successfully compute both the Sep2018 and Sep2018-Gridded simulation runs.
Keep in mind that discrepancies between observed and modeled results can have many causes. This could either be an indication of model issues (something wrong with the model itself), forcing data issues (something wrong with the precipitation or other input data), or calibration issues (the model parameters need to be calibrated). You should always fix issues in this order: 1) model, 2) forcing data, 3) calibration. This ensures you aren’t incorrectly calibrating a model to compensate for unrelated issues.
Model Summary
The Mahoning Creek project, named “Fix_Me.hms” contains three subbasins, one junction, one reach, and one sink (computation point). The basin is georeferenced (SHG projection) and has a standard structured discretization of 2000m grid cells. See table below for a summary of model elements.
Model element | Description |
|---|
Basin Models | There are two basin models, named Sep2018 and Nov2019. The Sep2018 basin model is the only one used in this workshop. |
Basin Methods | The following subbasin and reach methods are utilized in the Sep2018 basin model: · Canopy – Simple Canopy · Loss – Deficit and Constant · Transform – Clark Unit Hydrograph · Baseflow – Linear Reservoir · Routing – Muskingum |
Meteorologic Models | There are two met models, named Sep2018 and Sep2018-Gridded. The met methods used in each are: · Sep2018 – Specified Hyetograph, Specified Thermograph, and Hamon · Sep2018-Gridded – Gridded Precipitation, Gridded Temperature, and Gridded Hamon |
Control Specifications | There are two control specifications, named Sep2018 and Sep2018-Gridded, which cover a single event occurring in September, 2018. |
Simulation Runs | There are two simulation runs set up: Sep2018 and Sep2018-Gridded. Both of these need to successfully compute (and produce reasonable results) to complete this workshop. |
Answer Key
Access the solutions here: HEC-HMS_Troubleshooting_Answer_Key.docx