Partitioning by Grain Class Does Not Remove Fine Sediment From the Model
It is important to recognize that just because we partition mass by grain classes, HEC-RAS does not deposit finer sediment on the floodplain. HEC-RAS 1D only has one active layer and one bed gradation per cross section. Therefore, even if the floodplain deposits are reduced because coarse particles cannot theoretically leave the channel, the actual, numerical, deposits in the floodplain are identical to the channel gradation (e.g. they have the contra-banned coarse particles in them). Therefore, this method does not remove disproportionately remove fine particles from the sediment continuity simulations. HEC is working on other algorithms that can remove finer material.